Address by the Honourable Speaker: Upholding the Rules of the House and Maintaining Dignity
Address by the Honourable Speaker of the Montserrat Legislative Assembly, delivered at the sitting of Wednesday, 18th November 2026.
Honourable Members, Officers of Parliament, Support Staff, persons in the Public Gallery and those listening on Radio Montserrat and online:
I make this address today on UPHOLDING THE RULES OF THE HOUSE AND MAINTAINING DIGNITY – not to lecture, but because the dignity of this House is not a formality. It is the foundation upon which our democracy stands.
This Honourable House has been meeting since 1952. For decades, through hurricane, volcano, the loss of Plymouth and the rebuilding of a nation in the north of Montserrat, this Parliament has survived because of one constant: RESPECT FOR THE RULES.
The Standing Orders are not mere suggestions. They were reinforced by statute, commencing 1 September 2024—I refer specifically to Act No.18 of 2024: the Legislative Assembly (Powers, Privileges and Immunities) Act.
Directions from the Chair are therefore not only a matter of good manners. They carry the force of law.
I must now speak directly to what transpired in this Assembly on Wednesday, 7 October 2026, because there have been some misunderstandings, and misunderstanding left uncorrected becomes mistrust.
The action taken by the Chair in October was not personal. It was not about the individual. It was about where the individual was seated – in the Public Gallery, and what he was doing while seated there – using electronic devices.
Let me be absolutely clear on this point: The issue was not noise; not disruption. The issue was that use of devices in the Public Gallery is not allowed.
The term used in the Standing Orders for any person seated in the Public Gallery is Stranger. A Stranger is any person who is not a Member, the Speaker, or an Officer of this House. The term refers to support staff and members of the public. Therefore, a Stranger, no matter who he may be outside this Chamber, is subject to the rules for Strangers while he sits in the Public Gallery or attends sittings of Parliament.
On the matter in question, no previous indication had been provided to the Chair that the individual was present in the Gallery to provide support to the Opposition, as was later disclosed. No letter was sent to my office, and therefore, no announcement was made to the House before proceedings began.
The Chair therefore acted on what was visible: a person seated in the Public Gallery, using devices, contrary to the rules.
Had the Chair been properly notified in advance, the Chair would have known how to treat the matter and could have made appropriate arrangements. But the Chair cannot act on information that is not provided. I, however, thank the Hon. Leader of the Opposition for his co-operation in correcting that irregularity, which now ensures adequate facilitation for that purpose.
I say this not to blame anyone, but to correct the record and all misguided information, as well as to protect the integrity of the Chair in the future.
I urge everyone to look beyond Marjorie Smith as an individual. I am a woman from this island, serving as your Speaker. But I do not sit as Marjorie Smith when I take the Chair. I sit as the Speaker of the Montserrat Legislative Assembly.
The authority in this Chair does not belong to me. It belongs to the office. It belonged to every Speaker before me, and it will belong to every Speaker after me.
When a Member or Stranger disregards a direction from the Chair, it is not a personal disagreement with Marjorie Smith. It is a disregard for the authority of the Chair itself. And when the authority of the Chair is undermined, the authority of this whole Assembly is undermined.
You may disagree with a ruling. Standing Order 44 provides a remedy: a substantive motion. What you may not do is disobey in the Chamber, argue with the Chair in the Chamber, or encourage the public to see the Chair as a person to be challenged, rather than an office to be respected.
I implore Members to defend the Chair—the Office, even when you disagree with the occupant, because one day the occupant will change, but the Chair must remain strong.
If directives from the Chair are disregarded, there are consequences
1. For Honourable Members
When the Chair rises, you will sit. If a Member persists in disorderly conduct, I will name that Member. To be named means the conduct is officially recorded, and the Member may be suspended, will be deemed a stranger, must withdraw, and under section 8 of Act No.18 of 2024 may be excluded.
2. For Strangers in the Public Gallery
Under Standing Order 75, the Speaker has the authority to set the rules that govern this House. It is under that authority — supported by sections 6 and 7 of Act No.18 of 2024, which empower the Speaker to regulate admittance and to order the withdrawal of any non-member — that the rules for the Public Gallery exist and are enforced.
Admission to the Gallery is a privilege, not a right.
While seated there, a Stranger must observe in silence, must not use devices, must not record, take photographs, applaud, jeer, or otherwise interrupt, and must follow the direction of the Chair, the Sergeant-at-Arms and any Officer of this House.
If a person in the Gallery engages in any such activity without permission, or refuses to comply with the direction of the Sergeant-at-Arms or any Officer of the House, that person will be removed immediately.
This rule applies to everyone in the Gallery, without exception, unless prior written permission has been granted by the Chair.
If the disturbance is general, I will order the Gallery to be cleared. Law-abiding citizens will then lose the opportunity to witness their Parliament because of the adverse actions of a few.
3. For All Persons
Under Section 14 of Act No.18 of 2024, a person commits an offence if, among other things, he disobeys an order issued by the Speaker; obstructs the Sergeant-at-Arms; assaults, obstructs, insults or threatens a Member or Officer of Parliament; creates or joins in any disturbance which interrupts or is likely to interrupt proceedings.
Penalty on summary conviction: is a fine of $10,000, or six months’ imprisonment, or both.
Under section 15 of the Act—for disturbance that interrupts proceedings by a person in a group of 12 or more individuals, or a person who incites such interruptions, the fine is $19,200 or six months’ imprisonment or both.
Interrupting parliamentary proceedings is not just bad manners. It is a criminal offence.
In Conclusion
For the avoidance of doubt, let me set the procedure for the future:
If a Member wishes to have any person present in a capacity other than as a member of the public — including where that person may need to use a device to assist the Member — that Member must notify the Clerk and my office in writing, in advance. The Chair will then make and advise of arrangements for seating, and conduct, before the sitting begins.
That is how we avoid a repeat of October. That is how we protect the House, the individual and the Chair.
Honourable Members, let us lead by example.
Members of the public, I ask you to help us keep this House worthy of its honor. Come. Observe. Listen. Hold us accountable. But do so in dignity.
Let the sitting in October be the last time we need to have this conversation.
I so rule.
